The comments were lovely, thank you!
We had some poetry, we had some patriotism, we had some puns.
To keep it fair - and because I just couldn't decide - I used MS Excel's Random Number generating function, which landed on number 23. Number 23 is a comment from a knitter who logged in anonymously and signed in as Peggy.
So, mysterious Peggy: drop me an email at kate at wisehildaknits dot com and we'll get your goodies to you. (If I haven't heard from you by end of day Wednesday, I will draw another number.)